Create. Share. Engage.
Portfolios for learning and more brought to you by the Mahara team at Catalyst IT. Host Kristina Hoeppner talks with portfolio practitioners, researchers, learning designers, students, and others about their portfolio story.
Create. Share. Engage.
Malha Muhammed: Portfolio ownership that leads to growth beyond grades
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Malha Muhammed, BSc, a recent Dublin City University (DCU) bioprocessing graduate, talks about how portfolio work shaped her university journey. She used Loop Reflect, DCU’s Mahara site, to question what went wrong after each experiment, alone and with her team. That habit paid off: her group won a Portfolio Student Award for a project turning waste into renewable energy.
Malha shares how reflection shifted her focus from grades to growth, how her roles as class rep, peer mentor, senior peer mentor, student ambassador, and Vice President of Diversity and Inclusion at the Student Union at DCU built her confidence, and how she now brings reflective practice into her work teaching STEM classes to young students.
Resources
- Group portfolio by Malha Muhammed, Abbey Byrne, Ruth Lyons, and Aoife O'Neill
- Dublin City University student showcase
- Event 'Celebrating and sharing ePortfolio practice', for the 10th anniversary of Loop Reflect (Mahara) at Dublin City University; includes links to two new volumes of portfolio case studies
Related episodes with (former) DCU members
- Lisa Donaldson: From 0 to 6,000 in six weeks
- Orna Farrell: Supporting learners and lecturers alike in their portfolio journey
- Mark Brady: Journal regularly for profound insight
- Mark Glynn: Take a programmatic approach to assessment with portfolios
- Rob Lowney: Create collaborative portfolios to surface group learning
- Mark Brown: Learner ownership is at the heart of the portfolio
Subscribe to the monthly newsletter about Mahara and portfolios.
Production information
Production: Catalyst IT
Host: Kristina Hoeppner
Artwork: Evonne Cheung
Music: The Mahara tune by Josh Woodward
Welcome to'Create. Share. Engage.' This is the podcast about portfolios for learning and more for educators, learning designers, and managers keen on integrating portfolios with their education and professional development practices. 'Create. Share. Engage.' is brought to you by the Mahara team at Catalyst IT. My name is Kristina Hoeppner. Today, I'm speaking with Malha Muhammed, a former student at Dublin City University in Ireland. In October 2026, she participated in the event that the Teaching Enhancement Unit at DCU organised to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the university working with Mahara for portfolios. Thank you so much for joining me today, Malha, to share your portfolio experiences.
Malha Muhammed:Thank you so much for having me, Kristina. It's an absolute honour and a pleasure to be here today, speaking to you about my experience, not only as a former student, but also recent graduate, and of course as the former Vice President for Diversity and Inclusion in the Student Union in Dublin City University. So thanks so much. I'm absolutely ecstatic to be here today.
Kristina Hoeppner:I'm also looking forward to our chat, Malha, because I've seen the recording of the event, and it was really fantastic to hear how you've been using portfolios and also really inspiring others through the work that you've been doing at DCU. Malha, tell me a bit more. What do you currently do?
Malha Muhammed:I recently graduated in bioprocessing in Dublin City University, and of course, during my time there as a student, I was involved in a number of different aspects in university life, including volunteering beyond campus, and as I just mentioned, one of the most significant roles in my university era, I would say, was serving as the Vice President for Diversity and Inclusion with the Student Union in DCU, where I represented over 22,000 students, I want to say. I'm currently working as an instructor in CTYI, which is located in DCU, so the Centre of Talented Youth of Ireland. So my role is where I design and teach STEM-related courses to young students. They're between the ages of six to 17. So the STEM-related courses that I have dived or indulged myself in is nano science, biology, physics, and engineering. In particular, nano science is my main focus, where it's an eight week programme. So I'm currently an aspiring biopharma individual, where I see myself working in the biopharmaceutical realm. But my current work involves helping individuals who have this STEM spark in them and want to pursue STEM in university. Coming from a bioprocessing graduate to, of course, being a senior peer mentor and a peer mentor and a student ambassador in my student era, and progressing on to be one of the Vice Presidents for Diversity and Inclusion in the union, my pathway, my journey, is not being quite traditional, I suppose, in terms of like you know going straight into my field of work, it's very much leadership, advocacy work, and I'm hoping to move into the biopharma sector. So I definitely say my journey is never linear. It's never been linear from the get go.
Kristina Hoeppner:Yeah, that's an amazing journey already with your leadership roles at the university, now you're teaching, and then you want to go into more of a research role.
Malha Muhammed:Yeah, so I'm looking to, I suppose, with bioprocessing, when a lot of people ask me what it entails, I always say, well, it's like a professional drug dealer[laughs] is what I say because, like you know, you're working with your vaccines, you're working with your drugs. I wanted to study law when I was filling out my CEO, and that's where my career counsellors and guidance teachers saw me back in secondary school. And then unfortunately, I was diagnosed with meningitis, which is an infection of the brain. So it really just did change my peripheral view in terms of like you know what I wanted to do, what I wanted to study. I was intrigued by all these medical probes that were going at me, and I wanted to know like how I was diagnosed, in what way, how did doctors, how did nurses know this? It was contagious as well. I was so intrigued by the research and the study of my own self. So that's where I changed my CEO very last minute, and here I am now in much of a medical or a STEM related field. So I see myself in terms of helping other patients, other individuals. I've always been in that mentoring leadership programme role. I've been in mentoring programmes where I was the mentee. So it's nice to give back, and in my role as a class rep, a peer mentor, and a senior peer mentor, and of course as a student ambassador, I helped other students and prospect students navigate that spark and those questions in them and where they see themselves in university. It's great to hear from other people, and I like being that inspiring model for other individuals. It's an honour for me to be there and stand there and talk about my own experience and how it wasn't linear to other students. Yeah, hopefully I can apply my background in bioprocessing, of course, and all my leadership advocacy work in the biopharma sector as well. So fingers crossed. Senior scientist in the making[laughs].
Kristina Hoeppner:Definitely, and also with your background and also the diversity of the roles that you've already held so far, you have a lot of possibilities, and then can also see how you apply what you have already done. If we are focusing a bit on the portfolio work and how you've been involved in the portfolio practice at the university, what would you say there? Because I know you've created your portfolio since you've won one of the portfolio awards. But in which other ways have you been involved in portfolios in DCU?
Malha Muhammed:I suppose my involvement with portfolio practice at DCU developed quite naturally, I want to say, throughout my own degree, and of course as a wider experience as a student. So my degree bioprocessing, it's quite a relatively new degree. It's very hands on, very practical. Not only are we learning all these theories in our lectures, but we're also applying all the theoretical knowledge in the laboratories, as well as carrying out these experiments, we're working with different equipments, different techniques, and of course, we're working collaboratively not only with our peers but with our supervisors, with our lecturers, with the multidisciplinary team. Particularly in my final year, my course chairperson, Dr Brian Freeland really encouraged us to engage with Loop Reflect in general. So we started using it as a way to reflect on our lab assignments or lab sessions after conducting an experiment and all the practical work. So, for example, if let's say an experiment didn't go our way or it didn't happen as the way that we expected, we documented what happened, we considered the issues that were involved in terms of SOPs, mythology, equipments, what could we have done as a team, or what could I have done individually that was different if I was approaching that same experiment again? We wanted to be able to identify what we had learned, what went wrong, and how if we could have that chance to repeat that experiment, how would we do it differently. I suppose that comes naturally, and I'm thankful that it came to us in specific with Loop Reflect. I did it individually, as I said, with the lab work that I did. Even some of my own lab sessions where I did them by myself, but there's other times where I worked with my partner or I worked in a group of four, but nonetheless, I would still be reflecting in Loop Reflect individually. And then, of course, the group projects that we did, we had our individual Loop reflection as well as a group team. So I always say, like you know, reflection is really important not only for yourself individually to see the growth when you're doing it as a team as well, you're able to recognise all these strengths and weaknesses that you have, and how you're coming together to work on this project or work at your task at hand. It's great because it's definitely helped me in my own personal work as well. Because I suppose as humans, we're always evaluating our experiences. We're always doubting ourselves have we completed this task to our best ability, or like you know our personal to-do list, or if you're working towards an event, I remember being in the D&I work in the union. I'd always be reflecting on that. Have I completed the task that I was given, or did this event reach the targeted audience? Did I raise enough money for said charity? We do it natural as humans, reflection. But it's great to actually have a platform like Loop Reflect to physically have your words in front of you and all the mumble and jumble in your head to have it out there as well. I was very thankful to come across it in my final year. I wish I came across it much sooner.
Kristina Hoeppner:Loop Reflect is the name of the Mahara site that you're using at Dublin City University. So you've used portfolios in your final year, both personally as well as then also in a group. And for your group project, you and your other team members won the Portfolio Student Award for Best Portfolio. Tell me a little bit about that work. You've already touched on why you also use portfolios collaboratively, but can you expand a bit more on that portfolio, how it came about, and also how you, as a group, worked together to create that group portfolio, and then also to bring those reflective elements in as a group?
Malha Muhammed:Our group consisted of four other students, and our project was titled 'The optimisation of plant design for synergies between biomethane and bio-based products while managing feedstock availability'. So essentially, at first we were looking at how we could take these waste materials, particularly agriculture and municipal waste, and use them to produce something valuable rather than allowing these resources just to go to waste. We were working alongside GreenLab, which introduced us to the concept of circular economies, and of course, how we can rethink the way that we use these resources, particularly in the energy and agriculture sectors. So, for anyone else and yourself, Kristina, who might not be familiar with the work of GreenLab, it's a green and circular industrial park based in Skive, Denmark. Its work centres around bringing renewable energy, industry, research, and technology together to reduce the waste and make better use of these resources. So, one of the particular interesting aspects of this model is that the waste or excess resources from one process can become useful inputs for another, and that was the concept for our project. We were essentially looking at how our organic waste, such as agriculture residues and animal manure and food waste, can be used to produce renewable energy, rather than just simply being disregarded.
Kristina Hoeppner:I can definitely hear how passionate you are about your work. And so, looking a bit more at how you, as a group work together, did you divide things into different sections, and each one of you looked after one, or did you brainstorm things together and then huddled around a computer to put everything into your portfolio? And also, how did it work with the reflection? Did you reflect on your own and then put that into your collaborative portfolio, or did you submit a group reflection?
Malha Muhammed:There was two submissions that we had in particular with this assignment. So we had a group Loop Reflect where it was divided into different chapters, I want to say, and then we had a poster for this as well, where we presented it to the multidisciplinary panel. Both were group work, but we had our own initial individual reflection as well. So I suppose that could be the third assignment or submission. In terms of coming together as a team, as I said, my degree promotes not only individual work but also working as a team, and that's what it's like in the biopharma sector as well. You're given your own task at hand, but you're also working with a multidisciplinary team at the very end of the day, depending on what sector or route you go down in. So when we first got our brief before coming up with the ideas, we were researching individually. Then we came together at the table after maybe like 10 or 15 minutes of our research. I was constantly working individually and then coming back together, reporting as a team, and seeing where we can go from there. And of course, recognising our strengths and weaknesses. One individual is better at calculation and we recognise that from the get-go, where that person could take lead on calculation and another person can take lead on like researching. Yeah, so once you, I suppose, you recognise your strength and your weakness within a team as well, and that strength and weakness changes all the time. So it's not always the same. Once we recognise that, we allowed ourselves and, of course, other individuals in the team to take lead on that. So it's not like one person is a spokesperson. We were all spokesperson when we came to represent our project, and we took charge and ownership, and we felt proud in the work that we did individually when we came together. Having that discussion with your team members is super important from the get go, and I suppose holding yourself accountable as well, like it's it's not embarrassing to say this is my weakness. I wouldn't be the best at calculation, but I am more than happy to take lead on research or vice versa. I know working in team settings can be quite daunting at times because you're like, oh, I don't know if I'll be able to complete it, or I don't want to say that I'm not good at this. But it's all part of the learning process, you know, taking lead on that and holding yourself accountable and not letting your ego come in the way as well. There's benefits in both when you're doing like individual reflection, you're working within yourself and becoming a better person, like character-wise. But when you're working as a team, you're doing that for the benefit of the team as well and growing as a team.
Kristina Hoeppner:So one of the benefits that you've seen in your collaborative portfolio work was that you could work towards your strength individually and then really to the benefit of the entire group, and if you're looking at just your personal portfolio, there, of course, you have complete ownership of it and take responsibility for it. What other benefits do you see that each of these different types of portfolios have for students that you've experienced yourself or also seen with your other classmates.
Malha Muhammed:The best way to learn is from other individuals, and it's by looking inward as well. So other times you're learning through people, you're learning through yourself. I always say as well, like reflection and overthinking, they can work hand in hand, and can they always be misrecognised. But where overthinking comes, I suppose, is using that as a constructive feedback and working towards the goal of it as well. Reflecting made me realise, specifically with Loop Reflect, working as a group, the strength and weaknesses, and many hands on deck gets the work done, you know. And when you're dealing with yourself, you're dealing with your own strength and weaknesses by yourself, you eventually get the task done. But working as a group, you're able to recognise your strength and weaknesses, and you're able to have like one individual take lead on that because you know they excel well in it. And then you're also learning from them, and you're striving towards strengthening your weaknesses as well along the way. So what was once a weakness maybe a couple of weeks ago is now your strength as you're moving forward to the next chapter. So growth, you're seeing the growth visually, and you're seeing that in yourself as well. And it's great to have something to look back on in a couple of years, saying, "Oh my God, I can't believe that was one of my weaknesses." One of my weaknesses was working as a team, and here I am now, where I love working as a team.
Kristina Hoeppner:That is also testament, I think, to how group projects are set up at Dublin City University and that they are integral part of how you are studying, how you are working that you can overcome these negative connotations that you had before you got into these projects, that they are nicely scaffolded to make them successful and have better group experiences. In your address at the 10th anniversary of Loop Reflect, you had said that the portfolio helped you shift from the focus on grades to the focus on growth, and you've just mentioned growth as well that you've constantly learned that you've grown over time, that you've worked with other groups and have been at university. Was there any particular situation that helped you realise that you're not looking so much at the grades any more, but really use all the learning that you've been doing all the experience you're having, and realise that you have been growing?
Malha Muhammed:Yeah, you've definitely hit the nail on that because when I was a student in DCU, I was very much focused getting that pitch perfect one one, hitting the 90s, hitting the 80s, and not saying that DCU is like that. They very much encourage personal growth and being defined by more than like a grade on a paper. It's just the way that I've, I suppose, the way I build myself and how I've seen myself from a very young age. I didn't recognise that growth and I didn't give myself the credit until I graduated, until I seen myself on that stage when I received my degree, it was more so like wow. It was very emotional as well because I seen my four years of hard work come to life, and I didn't see myself graduating as well, especially with my prior diagnosis of meningitis. So it was a very much full circle moment. But it was until I graduated where I've seen like my growth, and if it wasn't for all the reflection that I'd done, working as a team, working individually, going through the battle, the storm, and every sort of weather conditions, metaphorically, of course, I wouldn't have gotten there. And it's all about the learning curve along the way as well. I particularly want to say my involvement in being a student ambassador in DCU really cracked my shell. I came from an all-girls school. I've always been that small wee girl in the corner, very shy, never spoke at all, and now I can speak to a wall. I can literally yap on for days. I give thanks to my student ambassador role in DCU, and I got more confident in public speaking, talking to prospect students about you know my field of study and my journey in DCU. It wasn't until I graduated I saw all the growth come to life. I wish I'd seen that before. I just don't give myself enough credit, and I always tell students it's super important to celebrate your small wins because collectively small wins turn into big wins. I always tell my own sisters this as well. Like you know, it's really important to give yourself credit because if you don't, who else will?
Kristina Hoeppner:So if you were to look back and give advice to one of your sisters, or both of them, or another student that is just starting out the university career, what would you tell them what to look out for or what to do besides giving themselves credit and also celebrating the small wins?
Malha Muhammed:I would say being able to say yes or no to things and learning how to say yes or no to things. University is more than a degree itself. Like I know if I just went through the linear traditional way, getting my degree and not involving myself and being a class rep, a peer mentor, a senior peer mentor, student ambassador, I wouldn't have gone into the union work, and I believe I still would have been that shy woman. But now all those experiences in those little leadership roles created the individual that I am now. Indulge yourself in like advocacy work and leadership roles in the clubs and societies. I've done some really cool things. I got to work with our former president of Ireland, Mary MacAleese, and if it wasn't for myself putting myself forward to scary things, I wouldn't have been here or there. And I was the recipient of the President's Award as well in DCU. So again, if it wasn't for me putting myself forward to these things and pushing myself, I wouldn't have been there.
Kristina Hoeppner:Yeah, don't just focus on the grades, but also all the other things around it because that transfer of knowledge and transfer of skills is so important because you learn so many things outside of the classroom through all the activities that you've been involved in. Malha, you've had templates to help with your portfolio work. What sort of support did you get in your classes or as part of your study programme when working on a portfolio?
Malha Muhammed:We had a really good balance actually between having guidance from our chairperson, from our lecturers, and of course having the freedom to develop our portfolios in our own way. Loop Reflect was always supported by the Teaching Enhancement Unit. So there was clinics along the way, resources, and support available if we ever needed help or just like where to start. If we had questions as students, we had um a great support from our programme chair. So any questions that we had, he was very approachable and open to supporting us throughout the entire process of it as well. So for individual reflection after each lab session, we had templates, so there were already proposed questions on the platform. So it got us thinking within that experiment, within that task. So it's not like we had to come up with these questions ourselves. But the more we did it, we had the opportunity to just, if we wanted to add a question, we were able to do that. In terms of like the group setting work that we did with the biomethane project, we were given leeway in terms of our decision to dividing the different sections of our project into introduction, technical aspects, calculations, and the conclusion of it all in different chapters, like different chapters of books. We were given that freedom in terms of creativity as well. So we both had the guidance and the leeway of doing that, and I suppose the leeway gave us the ownership that yes, this is our work. This is what we created.
Kristina Hoeppner:It's good to see that you have the scaffolding available, so you have the support, but you can also still bring in your own personality, your own creativity, and are not bound to a template very rigidly, so that you can really make the portfolio your own. Now, Malha, how do you use reflection these days?
Malha Muhammed:That's actually something that I've been much more conscious of doing. Actually, in my current role, especially as an instructor in CTYI and dealing with young students, I think it's really important to have this reflection embedded in their mind, so they can spark this creativity and have proposed questions in terms of like where they see themselves and triggering that part of the brain as well. In particular, with my nano science group, before I get them to indulge in the activity. I get them to predict, to get them reflecting, to understand what exactly happened. So I include little activities where they're able to stand up and think about it themselves, rather than just sitting in the corner there and just thinking about it. They're able to build a mind of their own, having that reflective mindset from a young age, just for them to have these questions for themselves and become better learners, not only in the present moment but in the future. I want them to be able to be comfortable within themselves to ask questions and experiment, and of course, allowing mistakes. Because I know when I was a student, it was always like, "Oh, I cannot afford to make mistakes." It's okay to make mistakes and learn from them. That's where the growth starts.
Kristina Hoeppner:What you've said that you also learned from failures or from not doing something well is something that can really be represented nicely in the portfolio, where you can explain how you then have grown and how that has contributed to you making certain adjustments or changes later on, and therefore getting to that success in the end, but definitely also showing that path that you've taken to get to it. Now, to our last three questions, Malha. Which words or short phrases do you use to describe portfolio work?
Malha Muhammed:I would say reflective, development, and empowering. Reflective because you're allowing yourself to look back at your experiences. And then development, you're seeing how far you've come and how far you'll go as well. So looking at the past and the future. And then empowering because my favourite part of Loop Reflect is the ownership of my own journey. I felt really empowered at the end of it, or even when I look back on it now, before coming onto this podcast, I was looking back at my Loop Reflect for GreenLab and the biomethane project, and I felt quite empowered. I'm like, wow, I've really come a long way. Because I was reading it through being a final year student, and now obviously I've graduated. It's great to look back on it and see that I've come such a long way.
Kristina Hoeppner:Yeah, if you were to talk to a former instructor. What tip would you have for them when they think about creating portfolio activities?
Malha Muhammed:To make reflection meaningful rather than making it feel like another assignment. At first, I'm going to be honest here and say that you know I looked at Loop Reflect as another assignment on my to-do list. I was like, right, we'll put that underneath the lab report and the MCQ studies and all that. But when I was halfway through like a bunch of reflections, I was like, okay, I'm actually learning from this. You know, I'm growing as an individual. I'm seeing different skills that I can transverse from being a student to also being a student ambassador or a class rep. So giving us, I suppose, a student, structure and guidance, which we got from the get-go, but also allowing us to have that freedom because when you have a structure, you're taking it as a chore but when you also have the right balance of having that freedom, that's when you can take ownership as well. So you're able to recognise your own mistakes from it as well, and not just the success of it, too.
Kristina Hoeppner:Now, for the last question, what advice do you have for portfolio creators?
Malha Muhammed:Be honest in your reflections. Include the challenges that you had faced, the mistakes that you had learnt along the way, and what did you learn about them? How did you come across these mistakes? And how those experiences are just as valuable in what you learned along the way as well. I always say life is more than just a straight line. It's more of like a winded pathway, and if you're honest about it from the get go, like that's where growth begins, like you know, holding yourself accountable and not allowing your ego to get in the way. I know it can be quite daunting, I know, especially having it like on you know a platform. Oh, I don't want to put my mistakes on this. I don't want to say this is where I found trouble, or I failed at this part of the task. But having that there in front of you, and then looking back on it and reflecting on it in years to come, in weeks to come, you can see the growth, and it's actually quite empowering to see that growth. And it makes you feel so accomplished that you've come such a long way. So if you didn't have that on a platform, you wouldn't have been able to give yourself credit. I know like it'll be in your head and all that, but like having it there as a testimony and having it there like as personal growth, it's quite empowering.
Kristina Hoeppner:Thank you so much, Malha, for reflecting on your portfolio work and also in the wider sense on your university journey of how you ended up where you are currently, and what your aspirations are for the future. It was really great to hear from you how you've been using portfolios, incorporating and having had them incorporated into your classroom work, but also how it has taken you beyond that, how it has helped you grow as a professional. So, thank you so much for the chat today.
Malha Muhammed:Thank you so much for having me. It was an absolute honour to be on the podcast today.
Kristina Hoeppner:Now, over to our listeners. As you think about your own portfolio work, what resonated most with you today? Share your thoughts on LinkedIn, Bluesky, or Mastodon, and tag me or send me an email. This was 'Create. Share. Engage.' with Malha Muhammad. Make sure to check out the resources in the episode notes in your podcast app or at podcast.mahara.org. And if you found this valuable, share it with a colleague who would appreciate it, too. Our next episode will air in two weeks. Until then, create, share, and engage.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Agile Ed
Dr. Lindsay Richardson and Dr. Ashley Thompson
The Moodle Podcast
Moodle
Teaching in Higher Ed
Bonni Stachowiak
Think UDL
Think UDL
Accessagogy
Ann Gagne
Happy to Help | A Customer Support Podcast
Buzzsprout
Let's Talk Education Research
Peter Tiernan
HBR IdeaCast
Harvard Business Review
OEGlobal Voices
Open Education Global